Why Imperfect Singers Can Make Perfect Country Records

Somewhere along the way, we got the idea that a great singer has to hit every note perfectly.

Perfect pitch. Perfect timing. Perfect tone. Perfect breathing.

Well, that sounds wonderful.

It can also sound boring as hell.

Country music has never depended entirely on beautiful voices. Some of the greatest country records ever made came from singers whose voices were recognizable within three words—not because they were perfect, but because they were human.

Johnny Cash didn’t need twenty vocal runs to convince you he meant what he was singing.

Willie Nelson can sing behind the beat so far you’d think the band left without him. Somehow, Willie lands exactly where Willie is supposed to land.

Kris Kristofferson wasn’t trying to win a television singing contest. He was telling you a story.

Bob Dylan built an entire career with a voice nobody could mistake for anybody else’s.

That’s the difference between singing a song and owning a song.

The Scar Can Be the Best Part of the Voice

A voice collects mileage just like an old truck.

Age gets into it. Cigarettes might get into it. Whiskey might get into it. Divorce definitely gets into it.

Life changes the instrument.

Technically, that might create imperfections. Artistically, those imperfections can become identity.

A 70-year-old man singing about heartbreak shouldn’t necessarily sound like a 22-year-old kid who just graduated from vocal school.

He’s supposed to sound like he’s been there.

When a singer’s voice cracks in exactly the right place, I don’t always want somebody fixing it. Maybe that’s the moment I believe him.

Modern recording gives us the ability to correct nearly everything. We can tune the vocal. Move the timing. Replace a word. Stack harmonies. Comp twenty takes into one performance.

Those are great tools.

But there’s a point where fixing everything can remove the person we’re supposed to be listening to.

Country Music Needs Characters

Country music has always had characters.

You knew Johnny Cash before somebody told you his name.

You knew Willie.

You knew Dolly.

You knew Waylon.

Their personalities weren’t something added after the record was finished. Their personalities were inside the records.

That’s increasingly important in a world where technology can create technically impressive music in seconds.

If perfection becomes cheap, personality becomes expensive.

A computer can correct pitch.

It can generate harmonies.

It can build drums, guitars, bass and strings.

But an artist still needs a reason for somebody to give a damn who’s singing.

That’s where scars, humor, phrasing, attitude and life experience become valuable.

I’d Rather Believe You Than Admire You

There are singers I admire because they’re technically incredible.

Then there are singers I believe.

Those aren’t always the same people.

Country music works best when you forget somebody is performing and start believing they’re confessing.

You don’t hear a singer.

You hear the guy whose wife left.

The woman who buried her mother.

The drunk who knows he’s screwed up his life.

The old man looking backward.

The kid trying to get out of a town that’s killing him.

That’s storytelling.

And storytelling doesn’t require perfection.

It requires truth.

So if your voice is a little rough, strange, old, cracked, nasal, smoky or completely different from everybody else’s, maybe you don’t have a problem.

Maybe you finally have something nobody else can copy.

In music, perfection is impressive.

But identity is unforgettable.

— Elvis Nash

If this hit home, there’s more where that came from. Connect with us on Facebook for stories about the singers who never needed to be perfect.